Jeremy Bentham

Utilitarianism

Hey there, Klouderz!

It’s Khalil, here.

Wow, what a session we had today at Coffee with Philosophy!

If you missed it, you seriously missed out on some mind-bending conversations that really pushed the boundaries of what we consider "the greatest good." We kicked things off talking about Jeremy Bentham and his utilitarian ideas you know, the whole "greatest happiness for the greatest number" principle. But then, as always happens with our amazing Klouderz, things got real.

Kasia, bless her philosophical heart, immediately brought up the classic:

Trolley Problem.

You know the one: a runaway trolley is heading for five people tied to the tracks, but you can pull a lever to divert it to another track where only one person is tied up. What do you do? It’s the ultimate utilitarian dilemma, right? Do you sacrifice one to save five? Our Nook was buzzing as we debated the cold logic versus the gut-wrenching human element. Is it always about the numbers, or is there an inherent wrong in choosing to end a life, even if it saves more?

Then, our very own Agus, who happens to be a brilliant medical doctor, dropped some serious real-world truth bombs. She explained how these life-or-death decisions play out in the emergency room every single day, right here in Florianópolis.

It's not some abstract thought experiment when you're faced with limited resources, critical injuries, and the pressure of time. She shared insights into how medical teams prioritize patients, making quick, high-stakes calls on who gets immediate attention, who gets scarce resources, and who, tragically, might not make it.

It's a brutal, practical application of a kind of utilitarianism, but with unimaginable emotional weight. It really highlighted that these aren't just philosophical puzzles; they're the harsh realities faced by heroes in our hospitals.

And then, just when things were getting really intense, Deivis with his incredible perspective came in with a beautiful counterpoint. We were talking about hospitals and the gravity of the decisions made there, which can feel incredibly heavy, almost sad.

But Deivis, with his signature blend of honesty and warmth, reminded us that while people often go to hospitals because they’re suffering or sad, there's also an incredible amount of hope within those walls. He talked about the resilience, the healing, the new beginnings, and the sheer human spirit that fights for life. It was a powerful reminder that even in the toughest situations, there’s a flicker of optimism, a pursuit of well-being that embodies a different kind of "good."

So, Klouderz, today was a powerful exploration of Bentham's ideas, pushed through the wringer of real-life scenarios and heartfelt human experience. We went from abstract philosophy to the intense reality of an emergency room, and then to the profound sense of hope found in the most challenging places.

This is what Kornerz is all about real talk, real connections, and real insights that you just won't find on a passive feed.

What did you think of today's conversation? Have you ever faced a real-life "trolley problem"? How do you see the concept of "hope" playing into decisions about the greatest good?

Jump into a Nook, share your thoughts in a Loop.

Others Klouderz want to hear your take!

Stay curious, stay connected, and keep that real talk flowing!

Wanna know more about Kornerz?

Check this out.